In a recent and unexpected interaction that reignited the tension between J.K. Rowling and the cherished stars of the Harry Potter film series, the author made remarks on social media that were interpreted by many as aimed at Daniel Radcliffe, Emma Watson, and Rupert Grint. This controversy arises from Rowling’s ongoing conflict with the trio, who have openly criticized her stance on transgender rights.
On March 19, 2025, Rowling commented on a post on X (formerly Twitter), questioning whether an actor or actress would immediately ruin a film. She referred to “three speculations,” adding, “Sorry, but it was fascinating,” and included a laughing emoji. The post swiftly racked up over 10 million views, generating speculation that it referred to the three actors who portrayed Harry, Hermione, and Ron in the film adaptations of her bestselling series.
The backdrop to this exchange is a complicated relationship shaped by Rowling’s controversial remarks regarding gender identity, which have led to accusations of transphobia. In previous statements, she argued that trans women are not women, contradicting views held by her former stars who actively support the transgender community.
Over the years, Radcliffe has expressed regret for the distress caused to the transgender community due to Rowling’s remarks. In a public letter through the Trevor Project, he affirmed his support for trans rights, stating, “Transgender women are women. Statements opposing this erase the identity and dignity of trans people.” Similarly, Watson has publicly championed trans rights, asserting on social media that “trans people are who they say they are and deserve to live their lives without constant questioning.” Grint echoed these sentiments, voicing his strong support for the trans community.
The rift between Rowling and her former collaborators began in 2020 when she made a post that ridiculed the term “people who menstruate,” which sparked backlash from Radcliffe, Watson, and Grint over the discussions surrounding women’s rights and inclusivity. In reaction to their criticism, Rowling maintained that her intent was firmly rooted in empathy and solidarity for trans women but held her ground, arguing that allowing trans women in women-only spaces compromises safety.
In April 2024, Rowling made headlines by addressing the issue of adolescent blockers. When fans inquired whether any of the former stars would apologize for their criticisms, she remarked that expecting reconciliation was “not safe,” deepening the divide.
The fallout from this ongoing conflict has elicited mixed responses, with some fans defending Rowling’s right to express her views on women’s issues, while others have called for boycotts of her new projects, particularly the impending reboot of the Harry Potter series on HBO Max. Warner Bros., the studio behind the Harry Potter films, continues to support Rowling and her right to express her views, which casts a shadow over the anticipated reboot and underscores the ongoing tensions within the fan base regarding the franchise’s future.
Currently, it seems Rowling is not inclined to mend fences with Radcliffe, Watson, and Grint, instead opting to use her social media presence to voice her opinions openly. Each public comment has reinforced Radcliffe’s commitment to respect the trans community, as he reflects on the nostalgia of his time in the beloved franchise while advocating for the inclusion of marginalized groups.
As anticipation builds for the upcoming Harry Potter reboot, tensions surrounding Rowling and her former stars complicate the narrative. The contrast between the actors’ former heroic identities in a magical world and their current engagement in real-world discussions about acceptance, diversity, and human rights presents a unique dynamic. Through their public statements, both Rowling and her former collaborators continue to shape the evolving narrative of their once-celebrated partnership, leaving it uncertain how these rifts will ultimately affect their legacies and the future of the Harry Potter universe.
